Sooo it apparently isn't any of the above! Get this... it's a wheel bearing all along. Yeah, came up to Eugene's (russianvr4) shop today and someone there notice that very wheel was pretty wobbly (can't feel it while driving). So I told Eugene and he said yeah that's gotta be it, causing the rotors to wobble as if it was warped and the pads are hitting unevenly. What explains everything, is that it actually tracks back to the accident my car was in two Octobers ago. So technically the body shop didn't get everything back to 100% that had been damaged by Mr. Curb. I'll update Tuesday when they're installed.